Ex-Post Evaluation

Evaluation Highlights on ODA Loan Projcets 2005

Expert Monitors full text Summary
Ryuichi Izumi(International Development Journal) - (PDF/75KB )
Shunji Nanjo(Yomiuri Shimbun) - (PDF/53KB )
Eietsu Imamatsu(Mainichi Newspapers) - (PDF/62KB )
Toru Takanarita(The Asahi Shimbun) - (PDF/57KB )
Project Evaluation full text Summary Third-Party
Opinion
Rating - (PDF/65KB ) -
Introduction of External Evaluators - (PDF/44KB ) -
Third-Party Opinion - (PDF/35KB ) -
List of Projects
1 Thailand Transmission System and Substation Development(1-1), (4),(5) (PDF/256KB ) (PDF/78KB ) (PDF/17KB )
2 Thailand Bangkok Water Supply Improvement Project (4-2)(5)
Networks System improvement Project		 (PDF/320KB ) (PDF/74KB ) (PDF/17KB )
3 Thailand Regional Road Improvement Project(1)(2) (PDF/307KB ) (PDF/60KB ) (PDF/20KB )
4 Indonesia Jakarta Fishing Port/Market Development Project(4) (PDF/205KB ) (PDF/63KB ) (PDF/68KB )
5 Indonesia Wonorejo Multipurpose Dam Construction Project(1)(2) (PDF/358KB ) (PDF/74KB ) (PDF/17KB )
6 Indonesia Merak-Bakuheni Ferry Terminal Extension Project(2) (PDF/207KB ) (PDF/95KB ) (PDF/100KB )
7 Indonesia Airport Safety Facilities Improvement Project (PDF/525KB ) (PDF/99KB ) (PDF/17KB )
8 Indonesia Ujung Pandang Water Supply Development Project(Stage 1) (PDF/378KB ) (PDF/64KB ) (PDF/18KB )
9 Indonesia The Bogor Agricultural University (IPB) Development Project (2) (PDF/118KB ) (PDF/68KB ) (PDF/15KB )
10 Indonesia Development Project of the Institute of Technology in Bandung(2) (PDF/118KB ) (PDF/67KB ) (PDF/18KB )
11 Indonesia Integrated Horticultural Development in Upland Areas Project (PDF/330KB ) (PDF/71KB ) (PDF/17KB )
12 Indonesia Sector Program Loan (PDF/265KB ) (PDF/66KB ) (PDF/38KB )
13 Malaysia Higher Education Loan Fund Project (HELP) (PDF/162KB ) (PDF/67KB ) (PDF/19KB )
14 The Philippines Pampanga Delta Development Project , Flood Control Component(1) (PDF/239KB ) (PDF/64KB ) (PDF/19KB )
15 The Philippines Arterial Road Link Development Project (1)(2) (PDF/299KB ) (PDF/62KB ) (PDF/19KB )
16 The Philippines Metro Manila LRT Line 1 Capacity Expansion Project (PDF/246KB ) (PDF/75KB ) (PDF/20KB )
17 The Philippines Environmental Infrastructure Support Credit Program (PDF/224KB ) (PDF/75KB ) (PDF/17KB )
18 The Philippines Subic Bay Freeport Environment Management Project (PDF/477KB ) (PDF/76KB ) (PDF/17KB )
19 The Philippines Metro Manila Air Quality Improvement Sector Development Program (PDF/244KB ) (PDF/78KB ) (PDF/19KB )
20 China Shenmu-Shuoxian Railway Construction Project (1)-(4) (PDF/213KB ) (PDF/65KB ) (PDF/20KB )
21 China Tianshengqiao First Hydropower Project (1)-(4) (PDF/121KB ) (PDF/84KB ) (PDF/37KB )
22 China Xi'an Water Supply Project(1) (2) (PDF/167KB ) (PDF/75KB ) (PDF/62KB )
23 China Tianjin No. 3 Gas Works Project (PDF/157KB ) (PDF/77KB ) (PDF/122KB)
Japanese
24 China Shanghai Baoshan Infrastructure Improvement Project (1) (2) (PDF/87KB ) (PDF/65KB ) (PDF/24KB )
25 China Xi'an-Ankang Railway Construction Project (1)-(3) (PDF/136KB ) (PDF/66KB ) (PDF/45KB )
26 China Guiyang-Loudi Railway Construction Project (1) (2) (PDF/130KB ) (PDF/69KB ) (PDF/45KB )
27 China Lanzhou Zhongchuan Airport Expansion Project (PDF/181KB ) (PDF/61KB ) (PDF/18KB )
28 China Interior Regions Telecommunications Network Expansion Project (PDF/333KB ) (PDF/62KB ) (PDF/28KB )
29 Pakistan Locomotives Manufacturing Factory Project (PDF/110KB ) (PDF/56KB ) (PDF/17KB )
30 Pakistan Diesel Electric Locomotives Rehabilitation Project (1) Diesel Electric Locomotives Production Project (2) (PDF/117KB ) (PDF/73KB ) (PDF/23KB )
31 Pakistan Indus Highway Construction Project (1) (2) (2B) (PDF/214KB ) (PDF/71KB ) (PDF/17KB )
32 India Anpara B Thermal Power Station Construction Project (1)-(5) (PDF/94KB ) (PDF/68KB ) (PDF/42KB )
33 India Yamuna Action Plan Project (PDF/111KB ) (PDF/72KB ) (PDF/20KB )
34 India National Highway 24 Improvement Project (PDF/271KB ) (PDF/64KB ) (PDF/18KB )
35 India Rajasthan Forestry Development Project (PDF/184KB ) (PDF/84KB ) (PDF/17KB )
36 India Industrial Pollution Control Project and Industrial Pollution Control Program (PDF/393KB ) (PDF/75KB ) (PDF/21KB )
37 Syria Al-Zala Thermal Power Plant Project (PDF/82KB ) (PDF/60KB ) (PDF/14KB )
38 Colombia Aguablanca Water Supply and Sewerage Project (PDF/167KB ) (PDF/72KB ) (PDF/17KB )
39 Tunisia Water Supply & Sewage System Improvement Project in Southern Tunisia (PDF/163KB ) (PDF/72KB ) (PDF/17KB )
40 Zimbabwe Matebeleland Telecommunications Network Development Project (PDF/98KB ) (PDF/67KB ) (PDF/38KB )
List of Contractor Companies - (PDF/47KB ) -
"Lessons Learned" and "Recommendations" - (PDF/47KB ) -
Thematic Evaluation full text Summary
The Philippines: Credit Support to Beneficiary of Agrarian Reform - (PDF/82KB )
China: Assistance for Environmental Improvement (Air/ Walter Quality) - (PDF/139KB )
India: The Role of Infrastructure in Alleviating Poverty - (PDF/85KB )
Tunisia: Integrated Management of Water Resources Chapter1 (PDF/1,183KB ) (PDF/106KB )
Chapter2 (PDF/1,440KB )
Chapter3 (PDF/2,457KB )
Chapter4 (PDF/487KB )
Annex I - III (PDF/64KB )
Annex IV - VI (PDF/109KB )
  • Column
full text Summary
Column 1
Improvement of Evaluation Seminar in Cooperation with JICA / PR Activities Concerning Japanese ODA Loan Project Evaluation		 - (PDF/39KB )
Column 2
More Efficient and Effective Operations: Collaboration with JICA / Response to International Trends in Development Assistance through Evaluation Activities		 - (PDF/45KB )