Ex-Post Evaluation

Evaluation Highlights on ODA Loan Projcets 2007

Expert Monitors full text Summary
Hideo Tamura (Waseda University) - (PDF/206KB )
A. Maria Toyoda (U.S.Villanova University) (PDF/2,898KB ) (PDF/106KB )
Kanji Hayashi (Japan Economic Federation) - (PDF/120KB )
Project Evaluation full text Summary Third-Party
Opinion
Rating - (PDF/116KB ) -
Introduction of External Evaluators - (PDF/122KB ) -
Third-Party Opinion - (PDF/63KB ) -
List of Projects
1 Thailand Agriculture Sector Loan (PDF/672KB ) (PDF/180KB ) (PDF/16KB )
2 Thailand Promotion of Electricity Energy Efficiency Project (PDF/208KB ) (PDF/105KB ) (PDF/12KB )
3 Thailand Lam Ta Khong Pumped Storage Project (PDF/434KB ) (PDF/156KB ) (PDF/618KB )
4 Thailand Wat Nakorn-In Bridge and Connecting Road Construction Project (1)(2) (PDF/991KB ) (PDF/110KB ) (PDF/15KB )
5 Indonesia Surabaya Urban Development Project (1) (PDF/638KB ) (PDF/165KB ) (PDF/15KB )
6 Indonesia Twelve Provinces Bridge Replacement and Rehabilitation Project (PDF/403KB ) (PDF/184KB ) (PDF/13KB )
7 Indonesia Professional Human Resources Development Project (2) (PDF/430KB ) (PDF/143KB ) (PDF/12KB )
8 Indonesia Small Scale Irrigation Management Project (3) (PDF/410KB ) (PDF/176KB ) (PDF/12KB )
9 Philippines Philippine-Japan Friendship Highway Rehabilitation Project (1)(2) (PDF/645KB ) (PDF/159KB ) (PDF/15KB )
10 Philippines Maritime Safety Improvement Project (2) (PDF/443KB ) (PDF/151KB ) (PDF/12KB )
11 Philippines Nationwide Air Navigation Facilities Modernization Project (3) (PDF/600KB ) (PDF/155KB ) (PDF/12KB )
12 Philippines Leyte-Bohol Interconnection Project (PDF/167KB ) (PDF/254KB ) (PDF/15KB )
13 Philippines Luzon Grid Transmission Project Associated with Private Power Project (PDF/398KB ) (PDF/132KB ) (PDF/15KB )
14 Mongol Baganuur and Shivee-Ovoo Coal Mine Development Project (1)(2) (PDF/542KB ) (PDF/130KB ) (PDF/12KB )
15 China Beijing No.9 Water Works Expansion Project (PDF/568KB ) (PDF/175KB ) (PDF/16KB )
16 China Guiyang Water Supply Project (PDF/503KB ) (PDF/175KB ) (PDF/15KB )
17 China Sanjiang Plain Agricultural Development Program (1)(2) (PDF/642KB ) (PDF/208KB ) (PDF/20KB )
18 China Power Distribution System Rehabilitation Project (Chongqing) (PDF/425KB ) (PDF/169KB ) (PDF/14KB )
19 China Hangzhou-Quzhou Expressway Construction Project (PDF/379KB ) (PDF/156KB ) (PDF/13KB )
20 China Wanxian-Liangping Highway Construction Project (PDF/340KB ) (PDF/193KB ) (PDF/13KB )
21 Vietnam Small and MediumSized Enterprises Finance Project (PDF/556KB ) (PDF/161KB ) (PDF/18KB )
22 Sri Lanka Samanalawewa Hydroelectric Power Project (1)-(3) (PDF/596KB ) (PDF/150KB ) (PDF/15KB )
Samanalawewa Hydroelectric Project (Reservoir Remedial Works)
23 Sri Lanka Telecommunication Network Expansion Project in Colombo Area (PDF/431KB ) (PDF/151KB ) (PDF/19KB )
24 Bangladesh Greater Dhaka Telecommunications Network Improvement Project (2) (PDF/282KB ) (PDF/125KB ) (PDF/16KB )
25 Pakistan Diesel Electric Locomotives Rehabilitation Project (2) (PDF/588KB ) (PDF/134KB ) (PDF/12KB )
26 India Western Yamuna Canal Hydroelectric Project (PDF/452KB ) (PDF/251KB ) (PDF/16KB )
27 India National Highway-2 Improvement Project (PDF/594KB ) (PDF/132KB ) (PDF/15KB )
28 India Ajanta-Ellora Conservation and Tourism Development Project (PDF/519KB ) (PDF/196KB ) (PDF/108KB )
29 India Bakreswar Thermal Power Station Project (1)(2) (PDF/499KB ) (PDF/127KB ) (PDF/12KB )
Bakreswar Thermal Power Station Unit 3 Extension Construction Project (1)(2)
30 India Construction of a Bridge over River Yamuna at Allahabad/Nain (PDF/414KB ) (PDF/187KB ) (PDF/16KB )
31 India National Highway-5 Improvement Project (1)(2) (PDF/1,036KB ) (PDF/169KB ) (PDF/13KB )
32 India Lake Bhopal Conservation and Management Project (PDF/799KB ) (PDF/204KB ) (PDF/15KB )
33 India Umiam Hydro Power Station Renovation Project (PDF/417KB ) (PDF/131KB ) (PDF/16KB )
34 Ecuador Transmission (Phase D) Project and Sub-Transmission (Phase B-2) Project (PDF/548KB ) (PDF/161KB ) (PDF/19KB )
35 El Salvador Road Improvement Project (PDF/540KB ) (PDF/148KB ) (PDF/15KB )
36 Brazil Todos Os Santos Bay Environmental Sanitation Project (PDF/691KB ) (PDF/155KB ) (PDF/12KB )
37 Romania Port of Constantza-South Development Project (PDF/718KB ) (PDF/179KB ) (PDF/15KB )
38 Azervaidjan Severnaya Gas Combined Cycle Power Plant Project (1)(2) (PDF/405KB ) (PDF/156KB ) (PDF/20KB )
39 Kazakhstan Irtysh River Bridge Construction Project (PDF/479KB ) (PDF/147KB ) (PDF/16KB )
40 Turkmenistan Railway Transportation Modernization Project (PDF/600KB ) (PDF/153KB ) (PDF/12KB )
41 Zimbabwe Mashonaland Manicaland Digitalization Project (2) (PDF/323KB ) (PDF/152KB ) (PDF/14KB )
42 Tunisia Goubellat Irrigation Perimeters Construction Project (PDF/305KB ) (PDF/158KB ) (PDF/23KB )
43 Tunisia Barbara Irrigation Project (PDF/311KB ) (PDF/188KB ) (PDF/12KB )
44 Tunisia Water Pipeline Construction and Irrigation Project in North Tunisia (PDF/472KB ) (PDF/135KB ) (PDF/12KB )
45 Morroco Rural Electrification Project (PDF/345KB ) (PDF/131KB ) (PDF/13KB )
46 South Africa Kwandebele Region Water Augmentation Project (PDF/275KB ) (PDF/139KB ) (PDF/14KB )
Thematic Evaluation full text Summary
Broadening Environmental Impact Evaluation Methods by Applying Environmental Accounting to Development Projects (PDF/73KB ) (PDF/109KB )
Application of the ILBM6 Evaluation Framework to the Lake Bhopal Conservation and Management Projects and Beyond (PDF/679KB ) (PDF/226KB )
The Effects of Private Sector Paricipation and Privatazation in the Electric Power Sector and the Modality of ODA Loans - (PDF/140KB )
Effects of Privatization in the Telecommunications Sector - (PDF/165KB )
Recommendations for the Evaluation and Administration os Sector Loan - (PDF/183KB )
Measuring Improvement in Capabilities of Administrative Officers as a Result of Scholarship Program - Cooperation with Universities
Ajanta-Ellora Conservation and Tourism Development Project(1): Special Evaluation from the Viewpoint of the Preservation and Use as a World Cultural Heritage Assest (PDF/230KB ) (PDF/207KB )
Figure1-5 (PDF/2,484KB ) / Figure6-12 (PDF/1,160KB )
Figure13-25 (PDF/2,851KB ) / Figure26-37 (PDF/2,967KB )
Figure38-44 (PDF/2,297KB ) / Figure45-50 (PDF/3,364KB )
Figure51-54 (PDF/2,618KB ) / Figure55-58 (PDF/2,158KB )
Figure59-64 (PDF/3,132KB ) / Figure65-73 (PDF/3,109KB )
Figure74-78 (PDF/1,891KB )